We humans are indeed cognitively impressive, but also spend much more time in crow-like proximate gratification than in future planning mode. There is a possible sampling problem here: we see the occasional chimp occasionally do something apparently clever (a word which can be an arrogant synonym for "human-like") such as transport stones for nut-cracking and we proceed to rank their intelligence on that basis, forgetting that many billions of humans spend much of their time in similarly unimpressive yet survival-compelled immediacy. The authors acknowledge this in their conclusion (my emphasis):Although various animals can plan and execute multiple actions toward a goal, they may achieve this without taking into account future needs, just current ones. Thus, when chimpanzees transport stones to use them to crack open nuts, or New Caledonian crows make hook-shaped tools to fish for insects, they do so in an attempt to satisfy their current hunger state, not some future one.
and note that this argues against the apparent future planning being just an unlearned activity like nest-building. Interesting paper.apes do not store food or objects in their natural habitats because those are generally available throughout the year
Comments are now closed for this entry. Try email instead. Thanks.
Movable Type 4.1 |
feed (add to Google) (validate it)
| Creative Commons license | xml sitemap | xhtml1.0 | css | File under: none, answer came there
ortholog.com: commonplacings, preponed futures, brainworthy memes, paradigm fragments, rigorously conceived musings, gists, free association on free science, stuff I have nowhere else to put. All the opinions and interpretations are my own. This site exists neither for nor despite you, but you are more than welcome to read it.