Dyson talks a load of spheres

http://www.techreview.com/articles/05/03/issue/magaphone.asp [Published: 03-Feb-05 | Permalink | Category: Science seen]
His analysis of Woese's recent paper on the obsolescence of reductionist science. Dyson says,

Now, after some three billion years, the Darwinian era is over. The epoch of species competition came to an end about 10 thousand years ago when a single species, Homo sapiens, began to dominate and reorganize the biosphere. Since that time, cultural evolution has replaced biological evolution as the driving force of change. Cultural evolution is not Darwinian. Cultures spread by horizontal transfer of ideas more than by genetic inheritance. Cultural evolution is running a thousand times faster than Darwinian evolution, taking us into a new era of cultural interdependence that we call globalization."

In other words, Darwinian natural selection was an interlude and has sown the seeds of its own undoing. Fascinating idea but doesn't it all sound a bit arrogant, almost crowing? The current age always has a high opinion of itself; are we really having so much impact that natural selection has ceased to have an effect anywhere? (Ask a bacterium.) Plus, I reckon cultural evolution has only been running "a thousand times faster" (whatever that means) for a few decades now and so, while we don't know the degree of inertia in the system, I'd like to see some evidence that cultural evolution has taken over so thoroughly. Cf theories of genetic takeover which were apparently total but this totality was illusory.

Comments are now closed for this entry. Try email instead. Thanks.

Movable Type 4.1 | common syndicated-feed-icon.gif feed(add to Google) (validate it) | Creative Commons license | xml sitemap | xhtml1.0 | css | File under: tricks of no trade in particular

ortholog.com: commonplacings, preponed futures, brainworthy memes, paradigm fragments, rigorously conceived musings, gists, free association on free science, stuff I have nowhere else to put. All the opinions and interpretations are my own. This site exists neither for nor despite you, but you are more than welcome to read it.