Lunatic fringe misidentified

http://www.nature.com/news/2006/061106/full/061106-2.html [Published: 10-Nov-06 | Permalink | Category: Science seen]
An utterly pathetic news story on Nature's site begins

"How would you feel if you were telling a patient they had lunatic fringe mutation?" asks Sue Povey, who chairs the Human Genome Organisation (HUGO) Gene Nomenclature Committee. It's a rhetorical question: the answer is that no one should have to make such an announcement. And Povey's committee is renaming a number of genes that have potentially offensive or embarrassing names so that in the future no one will.

Apparently, names like sonic hedgehog and the rest are a problem.

"It struck me that if I were talking to a patient and telling them the problem is that they have a mutation in their lunatic fringe, that would be an inappropriate conversation we were having," [Mark Ludman, medical geneticist] says.

Aw, diddums. C'mon, that's pathetic! Also bonkers. Surely it's a joke article? Those gene names are dorky, sure enough. But if you break the news to a patient about their unfortunate genetic variation with such breathtaking brevity, you have a lousy bedside manner and the sensitivity of a carpenter's thumb. Oh I'm sorry, dying person, I'm too hung up on the oh-so-zany name I forgot to mention the diagnosis and the prognosis and that a rose by any other name …. Suppose a woman has an inborn error of metabolism - do these politically-correct smurfs check her husband isn't called Gene? Just to avoid another "inappropriate conversation" in which her inability to smell may get blamed on her unwittingly named husband? When a Mr Bell turns up with a problem with his VIIth facial nerve do they mutter and shuffle and apologise profusely on behalf of history?
Seems pretty clear to me where the lunatic fringe really is.

Comments are now closed for this entry. Try email instead. Thanks.

Movable Type 4.1 | common syndicated-feed-icon.gif feed(add to Google) (validate it) | Creative Commons license | xml sitemap | xhtml1.0 | css | File under: bruxism, likely to induce

ortholog.com: commonplacings, preponed futures, brainworthy memes, paradigm fragments, rigorously conceived musings, gists, free association on free science, stuff I have nowhere else to put. All the opinions and interpretations are my own. This site exists neither for nor despite you, but you are more than welcome to read it.